
In Toronto, it takes a village, albeit a gay village, to bring folks together. On the eastern side of town, just steps from the University of Toronto and the bustling streetcars of downtown, lies Church and Wellesley, the neighborhood more commonly referred to as “the gay village.” In America, we tend to dub these enclaves, “the gay ghetto” or the “gayborhood,” but the Canadians, as they’re want to do, have shown a softer side. The gay village of Toronto is certainly not a ghetto, and it’s more than just a mere ‘hood. While it’s neither quaint nor conservative, it remains a village because everyone feels at home here.
Despite living in New York, I’m frequently disappointed at what our gayborhoods have to offer. Chelsea is full of men with no necks, no hair, and no personality. Greenwich Village is expensive and tame, though the vestiges of sex shops next to the Gourmet Garage recall brighter days. I’ll admit a preference for the East Village and Hell’s Kitchen, but these are hardly gay villages, simply boozy neighborhoods with bars and well-groomed gentlemen. Perhaps it’s simply because virtually every neighborhood in New York has gay nightlife, that we’ve forgotten about how charming a concept the village can be.

My fellow villager and I traveled from our nearby bed and breakfast, despite the cliche, and ventured up Church Street, the main drag of this queer neck of the woods. And drag it was. People watching is probably the only reason anyone even comes back to Church and Wellesley because god knows, it was not the food. I’m just as fed up with the now empty terms “diverse” and “multicultural,” but had I been sitting in the United Nations I don’t believe I would have used these signifiers so liberally. Not to be hyperbolic, but never in my life had I seen a gay neighborhood attract diversity beyond what kind of leather chaps one wore. In Toronto, the village people come in as many uniforms as the band itself, from lezzies on a ladies night out to a pair of older Indian fellows taking it all in with their cigarettes in hand.
American gay neighborhoods, and more broadly gay culture, are known for exclusivity. When one imagines a gayborhood, rarely do images of Afro-Canadian lesbians and Middle Eastern middle-agers enter the fray. In Toronto, the spectrum was truly as colorful as the rainbow itself. Perusing Church Street, we witnessed trannies work it with all the fiercness Christian Siriano could hope for, straight and gay couples double-dating, vibrating walls from a Caribbean gay bar, and bears noshing on Canadian hot dogs. Myriad questions flooded my brain, but I had to stop for hot dog to recharge first.

New York is outdone, yet again, by the genius of the Toronto hot dog cart. While I soaked in the array of ethnicities and orientations on Church Street, I waited for a freshly grilled all-beef dog. This was no 7-11 overdone, steam-heated wiener. The attendant took good care to char the outside and leave it plump in the middle, much to my satisfaction. I was overwhelmed upon paying at the bevy of condiment options including requisites like relish, ketchup and mustard, but extending to sweet peppers, cabbage, mayo, and corn. I may have overindulged on the spices, but the hot dog hit the spot nonetheless, providing the necessary protein for a night out in the village.
Further inspection of the scene revealed greater layers of the crowds’ diversity and the most popular club on the strip, a lesbian bar. Now I had seen it all, as people from every direction pushed for entrance into Slack’s, a beacon of a bar I’d never seen replicated in all my years of gayborhood travel. This hood had every letter of GLBT smashed up together like the spices on my sausage.

I’ll spare you the deluge of rhetorical questions that were spinning around in my head, but I still have not been able to conceive as to why this paradigm for a village is so lost on America. New York is equally (dare I say it….) diverse, yet certainly not as well integrated as Toronto. It could be simply that I’m not going to the right places, but one of the reasons I dislike so many of the gay enclaves in America is because one kind of uniform white, male, gay culture prevails. This is not to say that Toronto is not influenced highly by these forces, but the congregation in Toronto’s village certainly made for a more interesting evening than another prance up 8th avenue in NYC.

Beyond the easy speculations such as Canada’s marriage equality and history of embracing multiculturalism, I’m still quite perplexed as to why my trip to this bastion of a hood made for such a neighborly night out. Despite her loss, Hillary had it right when she spoke on the value of the village. Maybe that’s why she always had an in with my people.
